Question 1

What is the difference between a general surgeon and a specialist surgeon?

Accepted Answer

A general surgeon has comprehensive training to operate on many parts of the body, including the abdomen, digestive tract, breast, thyroid, and soft tissues. Specialist surgeons (such as cardiac surgeons, neurosurgeons, or orthopedic surgeons) focus exclusively on specific organ systems or body regions. General surgeons are trained to handle a wide range of conditions and are often the first surgical specialists consulted for abdominal problems, emergencies, and cancer. For complex cases, general surgeons may work alongside or refer to subspecialist surgeons.

Question 2

What is laparoscopic surgery, and is it better than open surgery?

Accepted Answer

Laparoscopic (minimally invasive) surgery uses small incisions and a camera to perform operations, rather than one large incision used in traditional open surgery. Benefits include less pain, smaller scars, shorter hospital stays, and faster recovery. Most gallbladder surgeries, appendectomies, and many hernia repairs are now done laparoscopically. However, not all conditions or patients are suitable for laparoscopic approaches - open surgery may be necessary for complex cases, emergencies, or when visualization is difficult. Your surgeon will recommend the best approach for your specific situation.

Question 3

How long is recovery after common general surgery procedures?

Accepted Answer

Recovery varies by procedure and approach. For laparoscopic appendectomy or cholecystectomy, most patients return to normal activities in 1-2 weeks and work in 1-2 weeks for desk jobs. Laparoscopic hernia repair typically requires 2-4 weeks before returning to heavy lifting. Open abdominal surgeries may require 4-6 weeks or longer for full recovery. Thyroidectomy patients usually recover in 1-2 weeks. Major colon surgery requires 4-8 weeks. Your surgeon will provide specific recovery guidelines based on your procedure and individual health factors.

Question 4

Do I need a referral to see a general surgeon?

Accepted Answer

It depends on your insurance plan. HMO plans typically require a referral from your primary care physician. PPO plans usually allow you to see specialists directly, though you may pay less with a referral. Medicare does not require referrals for surgeons. Even when not required, a referral from your primary doctor or gastroenterologist helps ensure relevant medical records and test results are shared, making your surgical consultation more efficient.

Question 5

What should I do to prepare for surgery?

Accepted Answer

Preparation includes completing required preoperative tests (blood work, EKG, imaging), following instructions about eating and drinking before surgery (typically nothing after midnight), taking or stopping medications as directed, arranging transportation home, and preparing for your recovery at home. If you smoke, stopping at least 2-4 weeks before surgery significantly reduces complication risks. Your surgeon's office will provide detailed instructions specific to your procedure. Attend your preoperative appointment and ask questions about anything unclear.

Question 6

When should I go to the emergency room for abdominal pain?

Accepted Answer

Seek emergency care immediately for: sudden, severe abdominal pain; abdominal pain with fever and vomiting; rigid or board-like abdomen; blood in vomit or stool; signs of shock (rapid heartbeat, confusion, lightheadedness); abdominal pain after trauma; severe pain in the lower right abdomen (possible appendicitis); or a hernia that cannot be pushed back in and is painful. For milder or chronic abdominal symptoms, schedule an appointment with your primary care doctor or request a surgical consultation.

Question 7

What are the risks of general surgery?

Accepted Answer

All surgery carries some risks, though serious complications are uncommon with modern techniques. General risks include bleeding, infection, blood clots, adverse reactions to anesthesia, and injury to nearby organs. Specific risks vary by procedure - for example, thyroid surgery carries risks to vocal cord nerves and parathyroid glands. Your surgeon will discuss the specific risks of your procedure, your individual risk factors, and steps taken to minimize complications. Choosing an experienced surgeon and following preoperative and postoperative instructions reduces risks.

Question 8

How do I know if I need surgery or if my condition can be treated without an operation?

Accepted Answer

Many conditions initially treated conservatively may eventually require surgery. For example, some hernias can be watched if asymptomatic, while others require prompt repair. Gallstones causing symptoms typically need surgery, but incidentally found stones may not. Your surgeon will evaluate your specific condition, symptoms, overall health, and preferences to recommend whether surgery is necessary, beneficial, or optional. Getting a surgical consultation does not mean you must have surgery - it means getting expert evaluation of your options.

Question 9

Will I be put to sleep for surgery?

Accepted Answer

Most general surgery procedures use general anesthesia, where you are completely asleep and feel nothing. Some minor procedures (small skin lesion removals, breast biopsies) can be done with local anesthesia or sedation. The type of anesthesia depends on the procedure, your health, and sometimes your preference. You will meet with an anesthesiologist or nurse anesthetist before surgery who will review your medical history and discuss the anesthesia plan. They will monitor you throughout surgery and manage your comfort during and after the procedure.

Question 10

How long will I be in the hospital after surgery?

Accepted Answer

Many general surgery procedures are now same-day (outpatient) surgeries, meaning you go home the same day. This includes laparoscopic appendectomy, cholecystectomy, most hernia repairs, and many breast surgeries. More extensive operations like colon surgery, thyroidectomy, or complex procedures may require 1-4 days in the hospital. Emergency surgeries often require longer stays. Your surgeon will estimate your expected hospital stay based on your procedure and health status. Factors like your pain control, ability to eat, and support at home influence discharge timing.

Find Best General Surgeons in New York

Top 25 General Surgeons in New York

About General Surgeons in New York

Cities with General Surgeons in New York

Related Specialists in New York