Carol A. Amico

Physician Assistant

800 HOWARD AVE, New Haven, CT 06519

Medicare Accepted

38+ Years Experience

Contact Carol A. Amico

(203) 785-2140 Get Directions

800 HOWARD AVE, New Haven, CT 06519

For Providers

Manage This Profile

Specialty

Physician Assistant Specialists

Coverage

Medicare + 5 Networks

Telehealth

Not Available

HPSA Shortage AreaScore: 25/25 • Dental

About Carol A. Amico

Background and practice information

Carol A. Amico is a physician assistant with over 38 years of clinical experience serving patients in the New Haven, CT area. She completed her medical training at Other and has been in practice since 1988. She currently practices at Yale University.

Carol A. Amico's clinical practice focuses on treating patients with high cholesterol, high blood pressure.

Carol A. Amico participates in Medicare's quality reporting program with a score of 73.6 out of 100. Carol A. Amico is in-network with 5 insurance providers, including Aetna, Cigna, Oxford Health Plans (UHC), and 2 more. Patients are encouraged to verify coverage with her office before scheduling an appointment.

At a Glance

GenderFemale

Experience38+ years

MedicareAccepted

TelehealthNot available

Education

Medical SchoolOther

Graduated1988

Are you Carol A. Amico?

Update your photo, bio, contact info, and accepting-new-patients status. Earn the “Verified” badge.

Claim this profile

Practice Locations

1 location

Yale University

Primary

800 Howard Ave

New Haven, CT 06519

(203) 785-2140

Affiliations

Hospital and facility affiliations

Yale University

Group Practice · NEW HAVEN, CT

Treatment & Experience

Clinical practice and procedure experience for Carol A. Amico

Treatment Approach

Carol A. Amico's treatment approach includes prescribing Bictegrav/emtricit/tenofov Ala (Biktarvy), Emtricitab/rilpiviri/tenof Ala (Odefsey), Darunavir/cob/emtri/tenof Alaf (Symtuza) for her patients. These medications are commonly used for treating high cholesterol, high blood pressure.

Bictegrav/Emtricit/Tenofov Ala(Biktarvy)

Emtricitab/Rilpiviri/Tenof Ala(Odefsey)

Darunavir/Cob/Emtri/Tenof Alaf(Symtuza)

Atorvastatin Calcium— for high cholesterol

Amlodipine Besylate— for high blood pressure

Source: CMS Medicare Provider Utilization and Payment Data, 2023.

Insurance Networks

Accepted insurance plans and networks

Carol A. Amico accepts 43 plans from 5 insurers, including Cigna, UnitedHealthcare, Aetna.

Cigna

In-NetworkView all Cigna doctors in New Haven, CT →

Az Localflex Excl Ebh And Pathwell

Az Localflex Incl Ebh And Pathwell

Az Localflex Incl Ebh Excl Pathwell

Healthpartners Qualified Network

Localplus

Localplus Exclude Ebh With Pathwell

Localplus Sar

Localplus With Ebh Plus Pathwell

Mvp Mohawk Valley Physicians

National OapOAP

National PpoPPO

National Ppo Sar 1PPO

National Ppo Sar IiPPO

Oap Shared Admin RepricingOAP

Pathwell OapOAP

Pathwell PpoPPO

Priority Health Alliance

Source: CMS Transparency in Coverage filings (March 2026). Network participation may change — verify with the provider's office before scheduling.

Quality & Safety

CMS quality performance and patient safety measures

Average

CMS Quality Score · Out of 100

Dr. Amico received a quality score of 73.6 out of 100 from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). This score reflects performance across clinical quality measures, care coordination, and use of health technology. CMS evaluates physician assistants annually through the Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS) to help patients make informed choices about their healthcare in New Haven, CT.

75.8

Clinical Quality

75.8/100

Measures the quality of care provided based on clinical outcomes and patient safety

51.4

Cost Efficiency

51.4/100

Evaluates how efficiently healthcare resources are used while maintaining quality

74.0

Health IT Adoption

74.0/100

Measures adoption of electronic health records and patient access to health information

40.0

Care Improvement

40.0/40

Reflects participation in activities that improve clinical practice and patient engagement

Source: CMS Merit-based Incentive Payment System

Patient Reviews

Reviews and ratings from patients

Loading reviews...

Is This Your Practice?

This profile appears in 5 insurance networks

Update your photo, bio, and contact info
Mark whether you’re accepting new patients
Earn the “Verified” badge

Claim this profile

Starter $29 one-time. Professional from $59/mo unlocks review responses, office hours, photo gallery, and more.

About Physician Assistant

Specialty overview and common conditions

A Physician Assistant (PA) is a licensed medical professional who practices medicine as part of a healthcare team. PAs diagnose illnesses, develop and manage treatment plans, prescribe medications, perform procedures, assist in surgery, and provide comprehensive patient care across all medical speci...

Common conditions treated by physician assistant specialists:

Diabetes Management
Hypertension (High Blood Pressure)
Musculoskeletal Injuries
Respiratory Infections

Learn more about physician assistant specialists

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Carol A. Amico

Does Amico accept Medicare?

Yes, Amico accepts Medicare assignment. Patients with Medicare coverage can see Amico and typically pay less out of pocket when using a provider who accepts Medicare assignment.

What insurance does Amico accept?

Amico is in-network with 5 insurance providers, including Aetna, Cigna, Oxford Health Plans (UHC), UMR, UnitedHealthcare. Insurance networks can change, so patients should verify their specific plan coverage directly with Amico's office before scheduling.

Does Amico offer telehealth or virtual appointments?

Amico does not currently list telehealth services. For virtual care options, contact the office directly or consider other physician assistant providers in New Haven who offer telehealth.

What conditions does Amico treat?

As a physician assistant specialist, Amico commonly treats conditions including diabetes management, hypertension (high blood pressure), musculoskeletal injuries, respiratory infections, wound care and lacerations, and other related health concerns. Contact the office to discuss your specific healthcare needs.

What medications does Amico commonly prescribe?

Based on Medicare prescribing data, Amico commonly prescribes medications including Bictegrav/Emtricit/Tenofov Ala, Emtricitab/Rilpiviri/Tenof Ala, Darunavir/Cob/Emtri/Tenof Alaf. The specific medications prescribed depend on each patient's individual diagnosis and health needs. Patients should discuss treatment options directly with Amico during their consultation.

What is Amico's quality rating?

Amico has received a satisfactory quality score of 73.6 out of 100 from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) through the Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS). This score reflects performance across quality measures, promoting interoperability, improvement activities, and cost efficiency.

Where did Amico go to medical school?

Amico completed medical training at Other and has been practicing since 1988, bringing over 38 years of clinical experience.

Where is Amico's office located?

Amico practices at 800 HOWARD AVE, New Haven, CT 06519 at YALE UNIVERSITY. You can reach the office by calling (203) 785-2140.

How do I make an appointment with Amico?

To schedule an appointment with Amico, call the office at (203) 785-2140. New patients should have their insurance information and medical records ready when calling.

Data source: CMS National Provider Registry · Last updated: May 2026